[Transcript]
Hello, and welcome to America’s First Ladies. I’m your host, Risa Weaver-Enion.
Season 5 Supplemental, Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton, Part II
We left off last week just as Eliza’s beloved sister Angelica Church was about to return to America after living in Europe for many years.
The Churches finally returned to New York in 1797, which is the same year that the Maria Reynolds affair burst into the public sphere. You’ll recall our recent discussion of James Callender’s publication of some of Alexander’s letters to Maria, which led Alexander to accuse James Monroe of leaking the letters, and almost resulted in a duel between them.
In August 1797, Alexander published his rebuttal to Callender’s accusations, and much like his uncomfortable confession to Congressmen Monroe, Muhlenberg, and Venable in December 1792, not only did he refute the charges of financial shenanigans, but he confessed openly and in great detail to the affair with Maria Reynolds. Why on earth he would do this, when he could have just chosen to stay quiet about the whole thing, is a grand mystery. He had claimed that he wanted to keep the affair from Eliza in order to avoid causing her pain, but then he went and aired the whole sordid tale to the public. It didn’t make sense then, and it doesn’t make sense with the distance of more than 200 years.
Naturally, we don’t have any of Eliza’s own words to tell us what she was thinking and feeling as the disclosure came to light. I suppose if her sister had still been in England, there might be letters between them to shed some light on it. But then again, maybe not. People were very guarded in letters at this time period, because you never knew when a letter would fall into the wrong hands. There is one letter from Angelica’s husband to Alexander that gives some indication of Eliza’s mindset. In it, he writes, “Eliza is well. She put into my hand the newspaper with James Thomson Callender’s letter to you, but it makes not the least impression on her, only that she considers the whole knot of those opposed to you to be [scoundrels].”
Granted, this was before Alexander published his full confession, but Ron Chernow speculates that Eliza would have understood Alexander’s need to unburden his conscience about the affair and to clear his name as to financial misdeeds.
There are two pieces of evidence to support this theory. First, as we already know, Alexander blamed James Monroe for sharing the details of the affair with John Beckley, which led to it becoming publicized by James Callender, and Eliza shared Alexander’s view of Monroe. To her dying day, she held Monroe responsible for the betrayal of her husband’s confidence. She seems to have blamed Monroe more than her husband for the scandal.
Second, after Alexander’s publication of his confession, he received a letter and gift from George Washington, that very subtly conveyed his continued support of Hamilton. The gift was four bottles of wine and a wine cooler, and Eliza apparently cherished that wine cooler for the rest of her life. If she had been unable to forgive Alexander for the affair, it seems more likely that she would have banished from her sight anything that would remind her of it. The fact that she didn’t seems to indicate that she somehow made peace with it.
To top off all the drama of 1797, Eliza also gave birth that year, to her sixth child, William Stephen, on August 4. You might remember that I mentioned last season that Eliza was pregnant when Alexander was threatening to duel James Monroe. Not his best moment, for sure. But he did delay publication of his confession until August 25, presumably so as not to upset Eliza during the last stages of her pregnancy. How magnanimous of him?
1797 had one final blow to deal to the Hamiltons when their eldest son, Philip, became ill and quite nearly died in September. The doctor tending to him went so far as to banish Eliza from Philip’s room “[so] that she might not witness the last struggles of her son.” Thankfully, due to some skillful treatment by the doctor, the young man recovered.
It seems that 1798 is when Eliza began to be more seriously involved in charitable works. She was a member of the Society for the Relief of Poor Widows with Small Children, and spent what small amount of spare time she had working with the organization. In addition to her own six children, she and Alexander had also taken in a young nephew in 1795. And then she gave birth to her seventh child, a girl named Eliza, on November 20, 1799. So she definitely had her hands full at home. But her son Alexander Jr. later recalled, “She was a most earnest, energetic, and intelligent woman. Her engagements as a principal of the Widows Society and Orphan Asylum were incessant.” She would continue these charitable endeavors for the rest of her life.
In 1800, Alexander began construction on a home for the family near Harlem Heights. It would eventually be called The Grange and was essentially a country home, meant to be a refuge for the family to escape city life. Because Alexander was still consumed with legal work, day-to-day oversight of the project and management of its budget fell to Eliza. But the house was an extravagance—the land cost $55,000, and the house and grounds another $25,000. It was well beyond the Hamiltons’ means, even if Alexander was diligent in collecting the amounts owed to him by clients. For context, that $80,000 would be worth more than $2.1 million today.
Tragedy struck the Hamilton family once again in November 1801, when their eldest child, 20-year-old Philip, was killed after a duel. He lived long enough to be transported to his aunt Angelica’s house, where his parents both rushed to see him. Eliza was three months pregnant at the time. Robert Troup later wrote, “The scene I was present at when Mrs. Hamilton came to see her son on his deathbed…and when she met her husband and son in one room beggars all description!” Philip lingered all night with his parents at his bedside before dying at 5 o’clock the next morning.
When Eliza gave birth the following June, they named the baby Philip in honor of his deceased brother. The boy was often called Little Phil. He would be the last of Eliza’s children.
The Hamiltons really lost two children because of Philip’s duel. Their second eldest child, 17-year-old Angelica, suffered a mental breakdown after her brother’s death, and remained in that state for the remainder of her life, which was long. She died at the age of 73, living most of it under the care of a doctor. In her will, Eliza asked her remaining children to be “kind, affectionate, and attentive to my said unfortunate daughter Angelica.” As you might expect, we have no other insights into what Eliza felt after the death of her son and the incapacitation of her daughter.
The next two years would be full of even more tragedy for Eliza. Her younger sister Peggy had already died in 1801, her mother died of a stroke in March 1803, and then her father died in November 1804. And you already know what else happened in 1804: her beloved husband also died, in a duel with Aaron Burr.
For the full details of the duel and what precipitated it, I’ll direct you to Chapters Forty-One and Forty-Two of Ron Chernow’s Hamilton biography. Since we’re only spending two episodes on Eliza Hamilton, I’ve been trying desperately to limit the amount of information I include about Alexander.
I’ll note though that he was uncharacteristically lackadaisical in his will when it came to providing for his wife and children in the event of his death. He hoped that his assets would be enough to cover his debts, but he had no real reason to believe that they would be. He also hoped that Eliza’s family would come to her rescue financially, writing, “Probably her own patrimonial resources will preserve her from indigence.” He was sadly mistaken.
On the last night before his duel, Alexander was not with Eliza. She and the children were at the Grange, while Alexander was in New York City. He wrote her a final letter, and then around 3 in the morning, just before setting out for the dueling grounds, he composed a hymn for her.
On July 11, 1804, at 7 o’clock in the morning, Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr faced off at the Weehawken, New Jersey dueling grounds. Burr shot Hamilton just above his right hip, almost the same spot where Philip Hamilton had been shot in his fatal duel. The wounded Hamilton was loaded into the boat he had used to cross the Hudson River earlier that morning, and he was rowed back across to the home of William Bayard. As they approached the New York side of the river, Alexander told the doctor accompanying him, “Let Mrs. Hamilton be immediately sent for. Let the event be gradually broken to her, but give her hopes.”
Eliza and her sister Angelica both rushed to Alexander’s bedside. She was at first told only that Alexander was suffering from spasms, but when the actual situation was disclosed to her, the doctor wrote that she became “half-distracted [with] frantic grief.” According to another attendee, Angelica was “weeping her heart out.”
Alexander lingered for the rest of the day. The following morning, realizing that he couldn’t survive much longer, Eliza allowed their children to see him so they could say goodbye to their father. The youngest, Little Phil, was only 2 years old. All seven of their surviving children were lined up in Alexander’s room so he could view them together one last time. He died at 2 p.m. on July 12. He was 49 years old. Eliza snipped a lock of Alexander’s hair as a keepsake, but was otherwise overwhelmed by her grief.
According to David Ogden, who was present, along with many other of Alexander’s friends, “The poor woman was almost distracted [and] begged uncle Gouverneur Morris might come into her room. She burst into tears, told him he was the best friend her husband had, begged him to join her in prayers for her own death, and then to be a father for her children.”
At some point in the next few days, Eliza read both the final letter and the hymn Alexander had written her. The letter ended, “The consolations of religion, my beloved, can alone support you and these you have a right to enjoy. Fly to the bosom of your God and be comforted. With my last idea, I shall cherish the sweet hope of meeting you in a better world. Adieu best of wives and best of women. Embrace all my darling children for me. Ever yours, AH.”
Alexander Hamilton’s funeral procession was the largest the city had ever seen. But Eliza was not part of it. She, her sister Angelica, her daughter Angelica, and her two youngest children, Eliza and Little Phil, remained secluded.
Eliza retreated to the safety of her parents’ home in Albany, although now without her mother there. Her father, already ill, took a turn for the worse after Alexander’s death, and Philip Schuyler died on November 18. Within three years, Eliza had lost her sister, her son, her mother, her husband, and her father. And her eldest daughter was all but lost to her because of her mental breakdown. A less strong woman might have just given up and died of a broken heart. But amazingly, Eliza lived another 50 years.
There’s no question that Eliza’s faith and her friends sustained her through this onslaught of losses. Shortly after Alexander’s death, a Colonel William S. Smith wrote to her with his sympathies and to let her know that the Society of the Cincinnati would be putting up a monument to Alexander. In her reply, she wrote that she prayed for “the mercies of the divine being in whose dispensations [all Christians should acquiesce],” and “The wounded heart derives a degree of consolation from the tenderness with which its loss is bewailed by the virtuous, the wise, the humane [and] that high honor and respect with which the memory of the dear deceased has been commemorated.”
Alexander left Eliza and their children in pretty dire financial straits. In a tale that will sound familiar to you by now, his years of underpaid government service kept them perpetually unable to meet expenses. He had property, namely the Grange and some lands in western New York and the Ohio River Valley, but selling them in a hurry to raise funds for Eliza would not get the best price for them. Gouverneur Morris outlined the state of Hamilton’s financial affairs:
“Our friend Hamilton has been suddenly cut off in the midst of embarrassments which would have required years of professional industry to set straight—a debt of between fifty thousand and sixty thousand dollars hanging over him, a property which in time may sell for seventy or eighty thousand, but which, if brought to the hammer, would not, in all probability, fetch forty.”
To top it off, her father’s estate, which was “only” $35,000, had already been mostly distributed among his eight children and their descendants. Eliza inherited only some land in New York and $750 in annual income, equal to about $21,000 in today’s dollars.
Gouverneur Morris came up with a plan to raise money to aid Eliza and her children. More than 100 of Alexander’s friends banded together to raise $80,000 for Eliza. The fund was managed by the Bank of New York and was kept so secret that not even Alexander and Eliza’s children knew about it. The bank didn’t acknowledge its existence until 1937.
The executors of Alexander’s will purchased the Grange for $30,000, and then sold it back to Eliza for only $15,000 so that she wouldn’t be homeless. She also successfully petitioned Congress during the Madison Administration for payments that Alexander had declined out of an abundance of scruples, such as the pension he was entitled to as an army officer and the lands that were awarded to officers after the Revolutionary War. She ultimately received 450 acres of land plus five years’ worth of the army pension, which was worth about $10,000 at the time, or a little more than $285,000 today.
Eliza did her best to educate her children with her meagre financial support. Four of her five surviving sons became lawyers like their father, and all of them except Little Phil fought in the War of 1812. The only son not to become a lawyer was William, who studied at West Point, became a surveyor, and died of cholera after heading west for the Gold Rush of 1849. As I mentioned earlier, after her mental breakdown, Angelica lived the rest of her life under the care of a doctor. The younger Eliza became caretaker for the elder Eliza, and they lived together until the elder Eliza died in 1854.
They first lived together at the Grange, along with the younger Eliza’s husband, until it was sold in 1833. Then they moved to a townhouse in the East Village of Manhattan, which they shared with Alexander Jr. and his wife—also named Eliza! So Alexander Jr. had a mother, a sister, and a wife all named Eliza, and they all lived together in the same house for almost 10 years. I can’t even imagine how confusing that must have been.
Then in a super weird twist, the two Elizas actually ended up living in the same house in New York City previously owned by Samuel L. Gouverneur, James and Elizabeth Monroe’s nephew who married their younger daughter Maria. That’s the house where James Monroe died.
Speaking of James Monroe, Eliza never forgave him for the role she always assumed he had played in making Alexander’s affair with Maria Reynolds public knowledge. She forgave Alexander, but she absolutely hated James Monroe. He went to see her before leaving Washington at the end of his second term as president.
A young nephew was with her when Monroe came calling, and he recalled that Eliza was very perturbed when the servant brought in Monroe’s card. “She read the name and stood holding the card…Her voice sank and she spoke very low, as she always did when she was angry. ‘What has that man come to see me for?”
She allowed him to come in, but then, as Ron Chernow writes, “[she] did something out of character and socially unthinkable: she stood facing the ex-president but did not invite him to sit down.” Monroe said to Eliza, “that it was many years since they had met, that the lapse of time brought its softening influences, that they both were nearing the grave, when past differences could be forgiven and forgotten.”
Eliza was absolutely not in a forgiving mood. She replied to Monroe, “Mr. Monroe, if you have come to tell me that you repent, that you are sorry, very sorry, for the misrepresentations and the slanders and the stories you circulated against my dear husband, if you have come to say this, I understand it. But otherwise, no lapse of time, no nearness to the grave, makes any difference.”
Again turning to Ron Chernow’s words, “Monroe took in this rebuke without comment. Stunned by the fiery words delivered by the elderly little woman in widow’s weeds, the ex-president picked up his hat, bid Eliza good day, and left the house, never to return.”
I thought about including this anecdote in the final episode of Elizabeth and James Monroe’s season, but I thought it would be more impactful to include it here. Eliza Hamilton was not someone you wanted to mess with, clearly.
As I mentioned earlier, Eliza also spent her widowhood serving the cause of widows and orphans. She spent more than four decades working with the New York Orphan Asylum Society, which she co-founded in 1806. In 1818, she petitioned the New York legislature and won a charter for the Hamilton Free School, which was established on land she donated in Washington Heights, Manhattan. She also worked tirelessly to burnish her husband’s legacy.
She didn’t think anyone had written a satisfactory biography of Alexander, so she convinced her son John to write one, based on Alexander’s copious papers. As Ron Chernow writes, “Eliza buttonholed elderly politicians and peppered them with detailed questionnaires, soliciting their recollections of her husband. She traveled to Mount Vernon and borrowed letters that Hamilton had written to Washington. She knew she was racing against the clock, against mortality, against the vanishing trove of mementos of the revolutionary years. … The immense biographical project was not completed until seven years after Eliza’s death.”
Eliza tried to erase herself from the historical record by burning all her letters to Alexander, but she preserved his letters and papers with what amounted to religious devotion. She re-read his letters so often that the paper literally started to disintegrate. She wore a tiny bag around her neck that contained a love sonnet Alexander had written to her before they were married. It eventually had to be sewn together because it became so distressed from the wear and tear of folding and unfolding it.
Eliza seems to have stayed in reasonably good health through her old age. One woman recalled, “When I first lived on the Hudson River, quite near her son’s home, it was still remembered how the old lady, past eighty, would leave the train at a way station and climb two fences in her shortcut across meadows, rather than go on to the town where the carriage could meet her.”
In her nineties, she made a surprise appearance at an event for the Orphan Asylum Society. She was “a very small, upright little figure in deep black, never altered from the time her dark hair was first framed by the widow’s cap, until now the hair was white as the cap. … [She] retains in an astonishing degree her faculties and converses with much of that ease and brilliancy which lent so peculiar a charm to her younger days.”
Eliza moved permanently to Washington in 1848, when she was 91. She was a highly prized citizen of the capital city, and a frequent guest at presidential dinners. In 1846, President James Polk wrote in his diary, “Mrs. General Hamilton, upon whom I waited at table, is a very remarkable person. She retains her intellect and memory perfectly, and my conversation with her was highly interesting.”
On New Year’s Day 1853, a parade of notables entered her parlor, including General Winfield Scott, New York senator William H. Seward, and even the sitting president, Millard Fillmore. As Ron Chernow describes, “When the ninety-five-year-old Eliza dined at the White House a month later, she made a grand entrance with her daughter. President Fillmore fussed over her, and the first lady gave up her chair to her. Everybody was eager to touch a living piece of American history.”
Eliza Schuyler Hamilton died at the age of 97 on November 9, 1854. Her death was truly the end of an era.
Thanks for indulging me in this pair of supplemental episodes about a woman who was never actually First Lady. If she had been, we would have devoted a whole season to her, but it would have largely been about Alexander and national events that Eliza was living through, because, as I’ve lamented about other women in this series, there just isn’t a lot of information about her. Even though Ron Chernow’s book is a biography of Alexander Hamilton, it is also the most widely cited source of information about Eliza, and not just by me. If you look at the Wikipedia entries for Eliza and her children, the footnotes are full of references to Chernow’s book.
Having read the book twice now, I was already familiar with the broad outlines of Eliza’s life, but you don’t really pay attention to the details until you process them and write them into a narrative like this. I wish she and Alexander had had the chance to be First Lady and President, but I’m honestly not sure it would have gone well. I don’t think Eliza would have liked being the object of all the attention. I think, like Elizabeth Monroe, she would have tried hard to maintain her private life. And Alexander was too thin-skinned and prone to reading insults into every statement to have successfully navigated the presidency. So maybe it’s for the best that their time never quite came.
Next week, I’ll release one more supplemental episode, recapping and analyzing what we’ve learned over the past five seasons about the Founding Era. We’ve covered a lot of ground, and I think it will be good to take a beat and survey the landscape before we dive into the Antebellum Period. I hope you’ll join me!
As usual, this episode was produced by me, and the music is by Matt Dull. Thanks for your support!